Pages

Saturday, January 16, 2021

The Golden Bowl By Henry James

The Golden Bowl
is the third Henry James novel that I have read. This is a classic story of marital infidelity. Though the two other books that I have read by this author had lots of inner introspection as well as analysis of characters and relationships, this book takes the prize for that sort of thing. This novel is characterized by pages and pages of analysis of people as well as their actions and motivations. Thus, while the plot is interesting it is not fast moving. James has fashioned a brilliant and unique work of literature that lends itself to slow and deep reading. I thought that this was excellent and I got a lot out of it, but this novel is not for readers who are looking for any kind of event driven story. This was written in 1904.

This novel is mostly about four people. Adam Verver is a fabulously wealthy American who is a collector of rare and fine objects and art. Maggie is his daughter. Maggie becomes engaged to Prince Amerigo. The Prince is a member of Italian royalty but he has no money. Before he knew Maggie, the Prince has fallen in love with a young woman named Charlotte Stant. The pair broke off their romance due to the fact that they were both poor. It turns out that Maggie and Charlotte are old childhood friends. At the time of the marriage neither Maggie nor her father know of The Prince and Charlotte’s earlier affair. Shortly before the wedding, The Prince and Charlotte go in search for a wedding gift for Maggie. Though they do not buy it, they come across a crystal bowl that is finely wrought but cracked. The bowl, which the novel takes its name from, becomes very important in terms of both plot and symbolism. A few years into the first marriage, Adam Verver proposes and marries Charlotte. 

The proximately is too much for the ex – lovers and The Prince and Charlotte eventually take up an affair with each other. Eventually Maggie discovers the liaison. As is typical of James’s characters, she communicates her knowledge to her unfaithful husband in a subtle way and quietly makes it known to him that she expects the affair to end. One of her prime motivations is aimed at preventing her father from finding out about the unfaithfulness of his spouse. All this is presented very slowly and very subtly.

The most important thing to say about this book, as I mentioned above, is the way that it delves in to the minds and actions of its characters. This is a deep and meticulous dive into the motivations and psychology of people. I would estimate that about 70% of the pages of this book are dedicated to this examination. Many other books are deep psychological studies. In fact, James himself has written other novels that dug into things in a similar way. It is the degree that this bookwork does these things that makes it so distinctive. I have read The Portrait of a Lady and The Turning of the Screw previously. Both those works displayed some if these characteristics, but not to the extent that this book does. In fact, nothing else that I have ever read comes close to the detailed examinations of life that James pulls off here. This makes this book a unique and special work of art. 

Something that goes along with all this is the complexity and unexpected aspects to the characters themselves. There is a sense that both Maggie and her father found partners partially because of their great wealth. I would have been easy for James to have portrayed them as unpleasant characters in order to illustrate this. However, on the contrary, they are very appealing people. They are thoughtful, kind and show absolutely no arrogance despite their wealth. In the end, though their wealth was used as kind of a hook to find partners, they are still attractive despite the riches. To me, this is complexity. 

The characters are different and complex in other ways too. At one point Maggie is considering that fact that she does not have strong feelings of jealousy,

She might fairly, as she watched them, have missed it as a lost thing; have yearned for it, for the straight vindictive view, the rights of resentment, the rages of jealousy, the protests of passion, as for something she had been cheated of not least: a range of feelings which for many women would have meant so much, but which for her husband’s wife, for her father’s daughter, figured nothing nearer to experience than a wild eastern caravan, looming into view with crude colours in the sun, fierce pipes in the air, high spears against the sky, all a thrill, a natural joy to mingle with, but turning off short before it reached her and plunging into other defiles. 

The above quotation is typical of much of the book. This analysis and introspection builds layers upon layers of complexity into James’s characters. As I mention above, the reactions and motivations of these characters are often unusual. This is exemplified by the fact that while bothered by her husband’s and friend’s affair, Maggie is really not jealous. 

The nature of the relationships are also unusual. Maggie and Charlotte are childhood friends. The fact that Charlotte marries Maggie’s father and technically becomes her step - mother is odd and the characters even mention that it disconcerts them a little. The fact that the unfaithful pair had fallen in love and wanted to marry in the past is also something that is not common in stories of infidelity. Maggie and her father also have an unconventionally close relationship and both her them neglect their respective spouses as a result.

James’s sentence structure is unusual and can be called awkward. Admittedly, I did not really know enough about writing to describe exactly why James’s sentences are so difficult, aside from the fact that they tend to be long. However, a little reading online indicates that many find him difficult because he uses subordinate clauses to excess.

The above quotation is one example. Another occurs when The Prince is contemplating his position in English society. 

He found it convenient, oddly, even for his relation with himself—though not unmindful that there might still, as time went on, be others, including a more intimate degree of that one, that would seek, possibly with violence, the larger or the finer issue—which was it?—of the vernacular.

To ease oneself into a book like this, a reader might want to start with The Portrait of a Lady or another James entry first. This may help assist reader with the unconventional prose style, as well as the novel's other peculiarities. 

This is a unique book for the reasons mentioned above. The deep and intricate musings are very interesting. It lends itself to slow and patient reading. Along with the depths that James plumbs here, the the book is a fascinating look at a handful of complex characters and relationships. However, I would only recommend reading this is one were prepared first. Folks going into this should not expect a plot driven story. Instead, it is a slow read about people. One also needs to be ready for James’s prose style. For those who are prepared for this, I would strongly recommend this as an original work of art that is like no other book that I have read.

90 comments:

  1. So, I love Henry James. He's one of my favorite authors. But this is my least favorite book by him. His prose just isn't as well-drawn and concise as in his other books, and I think it's because he dictated this book rather than wrote it out by hand himself. It's still Henry James, but just not James at his best in my opinion. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. i don't recall now why i read this at an early age, thinking then that, as i would have probably imagined, the reader would, in a future state of sophistication, have been, possibly, more equipped, socially speaking, to maintain a presence...

    sorry (haha).... i think the earlier reading of this put me off James for life; i've read some of his other stories with about the same reaction... kudos to you for your determination!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have never dared take the plunge into Henry James. Kudos to you for doing so!

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you can get through Henry James's novels, you can get through anything! Kudos to finishing this one. I'm glad you mention the excess of subordinate clauses -- that sentence you note is crazy. That's way too many clauses & commas -- enough to drive a copy editor like me - nuts. I'm glad you were able to get something out of the story ... likely too much subtlety for me. ... and marrying a friend's father I suspect can cause some problems - yikes.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Brian I just finished this a couple of weeks ago and in the middle of my read I saw you post on Twitter that you'd read it and a blog post would follow. I am so glad because I just can't write this up, so I have to hand it to you :)

    This novel could have lost at least 200 pages with all the repetition and "navel gazing." And yes, his sentence structure is indeed awkward. As I noticed in What Maisie Knew, here, he also has characters in dialog with each other repeat words and turn them in questions. He does this constantly and it annoys me to no end.

    He is very confusing to me, because the actually stories he tells are deep and interesting, which is why I keep reading him. But I think I have had enough of his sentence structure and character analysis for awhile or I will stick with his short stories and novellas!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Like a number of your commenters, I read James in my late 20's. Went through a phase and read about 4 of them. But he is oh so tiring at the same time. By the end I felt like he was pontificating rather than story telling, so I had to stop that particular journey!
    So well done you for continuing and helping to inspire or (re)inspire those of us left by the wayside.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Lark - I did not know that James dictated this. He certainly was not concise in his writing here!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Muddpuddle. I cannot imagine what it would have been like to read this book when young. The other James's books I read were less esoteric.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Debra - I would start with The Turning of the Screw. It is more accessible then the other two that I have read.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Laurie - It was challenging. It think that those 200 pages are what made this book so unique. I need to read more if his short stories.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Brona - I think that I would have gotten little out of this when younger. Even now, having gotten something out of it, I would wait a bit before I read more of him.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I read this novel several years ago and appreciate your excellent analysis of James' style. It is an example of James at the height of his powers as a novelist and, indeed, is a great novel. Having read a lot of James from various parts of his career I believe he reached his peak with this along with The Ambassadors and The Wings of the Dove.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm an early James person myself and like them pretty well. The late Henry James I've read--I haven't read this one--are tough and I've always heard this one was the most difficult. Congratulations!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi James - The style of this book is so unique. We seem to be in the minority on approving the book.

    I need to read both The Ambassadors and Wings of The Dove.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks Rheese. I guess that I should read more of the later stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I read the Ambassadors (late) & liked it pretty well. But Washington Square or Roderick Hudson (early) are much more simply entertaining. (Well, Washington Square is pretty tragic, but still...)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi Brian, Henry James and Edith Wharton are linked in my mind because my first experience with both writers (reading Turn of the Screw and Ethan Fromme) did not go well. But then a few years later I read The Bostonians and House of Mirth and what a revelation! It pays to give the great writers a second chance if your first attempt at reading them doesn't work out.

    Regarding Golden Bowl I would be curious how James explains Charlotte's psychology. Because Maggie is her friend and though one can make allowances for Maggie's father and Charlotte marrying to then go on and have an affair with Maggie's husband is a real betrayal.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I've read The Ambassadors, which took me forever to read but was worth it, and Daisy Miller, which was worth it without taking me forever to read. The latter is an early work of James, and I think the prose style is just perfect. The subordinate clauses that you speak of are kept to a minimum, but there's still plenty of witty pontification. It's certainly not Hemingway.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hi Rheese - I must give all those books a try.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi Kathy - Though I think that both writers are brilliant, Wharton is so much more accessible

    As for Charlotte and the Prince, the impression is that they were so in love, thrown together, and then somewhat neglected by their spouses, that they could not resist the temptation to be together.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hi Kirk. I really have to delve into more James. I think that his writing got more intricate or awkward as he went on.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I've been meaning to read some James but given all these comments I think I would not start with this one. I think the sentence structure would drive me up the wall!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Although I think that I would find the style of writing to be a bit difficult, the plot and character development seems to make up for it. Thank you for sharing such a good review. May you enjoy a lovely day.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi Lory - I probably would start with The Turning of the Screw.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi Belle -The book has its rewards.

    Have a great day!

    ReplyDelete
  26. I have not read this James novel but would like to sometime as I do very much enjoy is long, difficult sentences and sharp eye. Glad you enjoyed it so much!

    ReplyDelete
  27. I think I mentioned to you some time ago that Joyce Carol Oates read and admired Henry James. She too sometimes writes long sentences with many clauses and interspersed with the inner thoughts of a character. Though she does also keep a plot going! I don't mind that type of writing these days and you did a great job of explaining its difficulties for the reader as well as why you found it good. I have dug out my book of James's four short stories and intend to dive in soon.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I've never read much James and, frankly, never felt any need to. Of the ones I have read, I think Portrait of a Lady is my favorite. Thank you for reading and reporting on The Golden Bowl so I don't have to!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Yo Brother Man, This Does Sound Unique And Interesting - Hope The New Year 20BLK Jack Is Treating You Well - Also, Have You Ever Read An Element Of Trust?? Be Well And Stay Strong

    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  30. Hi Susan - This book was one that I really had to work my way up to.I cannot I cannot imagine James's editors went through.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi Stephanie - I would probably start with The Turn the Screw. This one would not be the best James to start with.

    ReplyDelete
  32. You made me laugh Dorothy. Portrait of a Lady was very good and more accessible then this.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi Judy - I need to give Joyce Carol Oats a read.

    What a prose style that James showed here!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi Padre - Things are going well in 2021 so far.

    I have it read An Element of Trust. I tried to Google it. It looks difficult to get information on.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Sounds like a fascinating book, Brian. I love this type of character probing.Those subordinate clauses require a bit of mental gymnastics! I haven’t read any of his books ...yet.

    ReplyDelete
  36. a powerful commentary as always dear Brain !

    i truly find it fascinating the way you say it all as beautifully ,briefly and impressively !

    i was finding this one really compelling because of the human psychology it deals with ,but then i read the sentences by the author and found them quite difficult ,i read the phrase repeatedly for sometime and then i could knew what i was reading
    still book about human psyche attracts me most ,i think that as science says it too that each of is a complete universe inside ,i would love to dive and know how these universes work
    ever person creates world around himself with the help of what he has inside and this facts feels so appealing
    i found the story and book both worth trying and i would love to read it despite of effort it can take to understand author's opinion
    thank you so much for rich and wonderful review once again!
    wishing you all the best for days ahead Brian!

    ReplyDelete
  37. I haven’t read this one. My only James book was The Turn Of The Screw, which I read for my university English subject. This one does sound a bit slow for me. But interesting that being rich doesn’t, in this book, necessarily mean you are horrible!

    ReplyDelete
  38. I've read a small number of Henry James novels but have donated to read more, including this one.

    I suspect your advice about starting with something like Portrait of a lady is a good one, because I agree that some of his prose can be dense and obscure.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I'm glad to see you reviewing a book like this. Henry James has always been a favorite of mine. I haven't read this novel, but I have it. I've been getting back into my Henry James collection.

    Take care!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hi Sharon - You should give this one a try, I am curious to see if you find it difficult from his other words.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Yo Brother, Bummer On The Google Search - Its A Fun Read Book About A Guy Who Hitchhikes Around The Staes For Two Years - Easy Read And Interesting Adventures - Anyway, Enjoy Your Weekend And Stay Hydrated

    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  42. This type of writing is unusual today. His evolvement of characters is excellent. It has been decades since I read Henry James. Thanks for renewing my interest.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Hi Susan - Indeed one rarely encounters anyone writing like James today.

    His character development was also unique.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I do like a good psychological study in a novel, and stories with a small cast of characters are usually interesting, but I haven't been brave enough to tackle Henry James yet. This one sounds interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Top parenting books, Awesome article, it was exceptionally helpful! I simply began in this and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Cheers, keep doing awesome!

    ReplyDelete
  46. Excellent. It is time to re-read the Portrait of a Lady. I enjoy the delving into characters as driving the stories.

    Odd side note here: Have you ever seen the movie "Fargo"? Picture Minnesota, snow, and peculiar people. The examination of the two bad-guys is so well revealed by subtle hints.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Hi Susan - The presentation of character here was unique.

    I have seen Fargo though it has been awhile. I do remember the characterization being excellent.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Brian Joseph,
    I've been away from all blogging for a while. It's nice to read about books online again!
    The characters in this novel (which was new to me) do sound very complex. Thank you for your thoughtful commentary.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Sending Some Vibes Brother

    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  50. Everything's so subtle with Henry James, but his novels of betrayal and cunning manipulation are devastating

    ReplyDelete
  51. Hi Harvee - The subtle is unique and it is James's signature.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Encouraged to read this by a teacher way back when, I found the issues 'too big'. Longing to say that if I were to read it today I'm sure I'd better understand it, truth is, reading your review, I'm not sure I would.

    As always I admire how you tackle these books; of the depths you reach, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Thanks Felicity - This one really is best for those of us who like unusual and slow books. Even so looking at some reviews three are some folks who like that sort of stuff who did not like this.

    Either way I think that I would have hated this when I was younger.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Let Me Know If You Are Stream Live At The Moment - Would Make My Day

    ReplyDelete
  55. The Golden Bowl sounds interesting and I like the first quote you shared. I think if I were to read this author I'd read The Portrait of a Lady. Lately I'm not too into slow books like this one, my attention span is shorter now I think.
    Great review as always. Stay well.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Hi Padre - I do not stream live but I have thought about it.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Hi Naida - I thought that The Portrait of a Lady was a lot more accessible. I would start with that or perhaps A Turning of the Screw.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Hi Muddpuddle - Happy Belated Easter!

    ReplyDelete
  59. Hi Padre - I am good and all is well. I just need to get my blogging spirit back. I think I will soon!

    ReplyDelete
  60. just here to drop best wishes fr you and family Brain!
    i hope all is nice in your lovely world
    peace ,health and happiness to you and yours!

    ReplyDelete
  61. It took me a while to read Henry James, two degrees in English, before I tried it and was hooked. This is one of my favorites, the Golden Bowl. American freshness and naivete versus European intrigue, in those days, that is. It's different now.

    ReplyDelete
  62. Are you OK Brian? Long time no hear. Hope it's just that you are busy.

    ReplyDelete
  63. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Hi Brian, hope you are well. Missing your book reviews!!

    ReplyDelete
  65. I'm with Carol. Hoping everything is well with you. Blessings!

    ReplyDelete
  66. Hi Baili and Sharon - Thank you all for your concern . I am well!

    For some reason I did not get notifications that there were comments here.

    I have been in a Blogging rut.

    I do intend to return though. I need to get back on the horse!

    I hope to be chatting with everyone soon here and on your blogs.

    ReplyDelete
  67. Check In Soon - Spring Time Is In The Air - Stay Strong

    Cheers

    ReplyDelete
  68. Glad to hear from you! You know how the imagination runs away with one. Does he have CoVid...? I'll be praying that God end your rut. (I know, I know, you're not a believer, but I am...)

    ReplyDelete
  69. Glad to hear that you may be back blogging away soon. All the best to you in your recovery.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Hi Brian, Trusting you are just having a bloggy slump and all is otherwise well.
    X

    ReplyDelete
  71. Fantasy Power 11 if you have a good knowledge of Cricket you Can play daily online ,live cricket games,
    cricket online games, best cricket games, play cricket online, cricket game online at best cricket games app for android phones to win real
    cash and amount to instant approve in your bank or Paytm wallet.
    play cricket online

    ReplyDelete
  72. thank you for kind response dear Brain !

    i am glad that all is fine about you ,wishing you best of luck for all you into!
    hope you be back soon with your wonderful blogging soon.
    blessings!

    ReplyDelete
  73. Brian, delighted to know that you intend to return to the blogging and that you are okay. All the best.

    ReplyDelete
  74. One of my favorite authors, Henry James!

    ReplyDelete
  75. So Nothing Out Of Camp B - U Good???

    ReplyDelete
  76. this was relief to learn about your well being Brain !

    i am grateful that you re doing fine just facing timely blogging block which is normal thing and will pass eventually .
    please stay safe and healthy !

    waiting for your amazing posts just keep in mind ,let me tell you i am reading Sapiens which recommended my eldest son and finding it wonderful to learn about human evolution .
    blessings!

    ReplyDelete
  77. you have a good knowledge of Cricket you Can play daily online ,live cricket games,
    cricket online games, best cricket games, play cricket online, cricket game online at best cricket games app for android phones to win real
    cash and amount to instant approve in your bank or Paytm wallet.
    cricket game online

    ReplyDelete
  78. I see that as of May 5 you were still among the living, anyway... I go to check your blog every once in a while only to realize that you're still on sabbatical, lol... I'm still plugging away @ mudpuddlesoup2.blogspot.com... hope to see you some time... be well...

    ReplyDelete
  79. Altho I have been here before, I wanted to let you know that I am appreciating your writing. Your writing and viewpoints always make me think.

    ReplyDelete
  80. hope and pray all is well at your end dear Brain!

    best wishes and prays!

    ReplyDelete
  81. Already left a comment some time ago. Just wanted to check if you are still writing.

    ReplyDelete
  82. dropping you best wishes and pray that may all is fine and great with you and yours!

    ReplyDelete
  83. Buy cheap nembutal pentobarbital pills, liquid, powder, SECONAL FOR SALE ONLINE, SECONAL and more online.
Buy nembutal online, order nembutal online, purchase cheap nembutal online.


    CONTACT Email: soloblinn@gmail.com

    Are you terminally sick , weak , depressed and want to give up your life from the pain of the world? Have you been searching for a reliable and efficient means to get peaceful death without loosing your money ? Have you ever heard about Nembutal Pentobarbital Sodium Solution Peaceful exit medication? We are here to provide you with a peaceful and reliable solution.

    If you are looking to Buy Nembutal Online, then you are at the right place to make your purchase. Look no further, contact us and purchase Nembutal Online at a very affordable price. We have over 9 years of experience supplying nembutal to United States, Canada, Europe, Australia, Africa, Asia with 99.9% successful delivery.

    We are determined in giving real hope and everlasting rest to the terminally ill. We sell Nembutal Powder, Oral Nembutal Liquid and Nembutal Pills. Just providing your age and your weight, we will be able to provide you accurate information about Price, shipping, and payment.

    Note that, we do 100% discrete and express shipping of Nembutal world wide and have a refund/return policy to ensure maximum satisfaction of our clients. If we do not treat you well, tell us and if we treat you good tell the world.

    We are available 24/7 to answer all your question regarding HOW TO BUY NEMBUTAL ONLINE, WHERE TO BUY NEMBUTAL, BEST TYPE OF NEMBUTAL TO BUY etc. Simply send us an email and one of our customer service consultants will get back to you on time.


    * Nembutal suicide dose,
    * How to obtain Seconal,
    * How to buy nembutal Online,
    * Purchase nembutal Online,
    * nembutal online pharmacy,
    * obtaining nembutal online,
    * nembutal,
    * nembutal online,
    * nembutal for sale,
    * nembutal pills,
    * where can i buy nembutal,
    * where to buy nembutal,
    * buy nembutal online,
    * nembutal purchase,
    * nembutal price,
    * nembutal buy,
    * buy nembutal,
    * nembutal pentobarbital for sale,
    * purchase nembutal,
    * nembutal capsules,
    * nembutal sale,
    * nembutal for sale online,
    * nembutal buy online,
    * where to buy nembutal online,
    * buy nembutal capsules,
    * nembutal pills for sale,
    * purchasing nembutal online,
    * pentobarbital sodium nembutal,
    * buy nembutal pentobarbital sodium online,
    * order nembutal,
    * where can i buy nembutal tablets,
    * what is nembutal prescribed for,
    * veterinary nembutal online,
    * suicide by nembutal,
    * seconal nembutal,
    * nembutal no prescription,
    * nembutal pentobarbital sodium,
    * nembutal pills online,
    * nembutal suppliers,
    We are a legitimate supplier for Nembutal. End the suffering, End the pain and End your sorrow by purchasing Nembutal online from the best nembutal suppliers. 100% Fast, Reliable, Trustworthy, the product being of high quality, everywhere accessible, extremely pure, Nembutal powder as well as liquid and pills ,the best decision to make. Dying with peacefulness, Dying with dignity, Peaceful euthanasia, Peaceful mind. Consumption and order to be placed according to the need. 


    CONTACT Email: soloblinn@gmail.com

    Best drugs for suicide overdose, buy nembutal pentobarbital sodium online, can you purchase nembutal online, how much nembutal is fatal, how to acquire nembutal, how to buy nembutal online, how to get sodium pentobarbital, how to obtain pentobarbital, how to obtain seconal, nembutal by mail order, nembutal for sale, nembutal online, nembutal online pharmacy, order nembutal online, nembutal pentobarbital for sale, nembutal pills for sale, nembutal powder for sale online, nembutal price, nembutal suicide dose, obtaining nembutal online, pentobarbital nembutal sale, purchase nembutal online, sodium pentobarbital, sodium pentobarbital euthanasia, sodium pentobarbital for sale, sodium pentobarbital purchase, sodium pentobarbital suicide, sodium pentobarbital suppliers, where can i purchase nembutal, where to buy sodium pentobarbital.

    ReplyDelete